This site is intended for health professionals only

Practices could receive incorrect QOF payments following IT update

by Carolyn Wickware
27 September 2018

Share this article

GP practices using EMIS Web may receive incorrect QOF payments at the end of the year, as a result of NHS Digital’s push to replace Read codes.
Experts have warned that patients are being erroneously added to disease registers and, as a result, practices are facing greater workload to determine which patients genuinely need treatment. 
They added that, unless the problem is ironed out by the end of the year, practices’ payments may be affected.
The errors included patients with ‘post concussive disorder’ being placed on the QOF dementia register, while patients coded as being ‘tired all the time’ were automatically added to the depression register.
NHS Digital said it is aware of the issue and is carrying out a review to determine whether changes are required.
The problems have arisen after NHS Digital updated the QOF business rules to align with the new ‘SNOMED’ CT clinical vocabulary earlier this year.
But the translation method used by EMIS, implemented earlier this month, has led to the errors, according to QOF expert Dr Gavin Jamie.

What GPs need to know about SNOMED CT

Dr Jamie said: ‘If you go into Google translate and translate things into another language and back, it doesn’t quite come out the same, and we’re getting the same sort of effect here.’
According to Dr Jamie, GP practices using SystmOne have not been affected by the issue.
Dr Jamie, who is also a GP in Swindon, warned that unless the problem is ironed out before the end of the year, practices stand to receive incorrect payments for QOF.
He said: ‘We’ve got a 25-year-old on the dementia register who doesn’t have dementia but technically the rules are now saying we have to do a dementia review on this guy, which we won’t do because it’s silly. That can affect payment at the end of the year, if these things are still going on.’
He also warned that the problem was causing added workload for GPs, who had to review which patients were genuinely in need of certain reviews and treatments.
Dr Jamie told Pulse: ‘It’s all about identifying which patients need a review or need a blood test or a flu jab, disrupting that certainly generates more work.’
SNOMED is a ‘structured clinical vocabulary’, which allows GPs add a code to patients’ electronic health record that corresponds with diagnoses, procedures, symptoms, family history, allergies, assessment tools, observations and healthcare devices. 
NHS Digital is aiming for all GP practices to transition to using SNOMED by the end of this calendar year.
It has said the reason for this is because parts of the Read code vocabulary database ‘are full and new codes have been allocated to unrelated areas’, making it difficult to analyse how the codes are used. 
Also, SNOMED is already used widely in hospitals and NHS Digital has said it is looking to create a ‘single clinical terminology, for clinical data to be exchanged accurately and consistently across all care settings’.
To date, 20 practices have been piloting the clinical coding system since April this year.
NHS Digital’s head of primary care information Dave Roberts said: ‘We are aware of a query around the business rules for post-concussion syndrome and our clinical advisors are currently carrying out a review to determine whether changes are required, as is our approach to any potential issue with business rules.’
NHS Digital added that further changes to the QOF specifications are planned following the October SNOMED CT code release and testing will begin in December 2018, with any changes to specifications identified prior to this testing to be included in the updated QOF specification.
EMIS declined to comment.

This story was first published on our sister publication Pulse.